Fun / Stories Shared

Real Winemakers Read Wine Spectator Reviews #2: Jean-Charles Boisset reads Thomas Matthews

still of Jean-Charles Boisset, proprietor of the Boisset Collections speaking to the camera for a video by Jordan Winery

Why hasn’t anyone ever made a video of someone reading a long-form wine review? Maybe, just maybe, wine lovers might find it as amusing as foodies did Yelp review readings. We decided to give it a try.

Wine Spectator‘s video contest is our one time a year to break out from the usual behind-the-scenes winemaking and hospitality videos–and create videos to make wine lovers laugh (hopefully). Funny submissions have made the finals in the past, so we thought this concept might make Spectator editors smile. Our contest submissions are not intended to poke fun at the original authors; they are meant to be an entertaining tribute to the passion and detail noted wine critics put into their prose. Wine Spectator’s What We’re Drinking Now column archives were our creative playground.

We like to think of these videos as an opportunity for wine lovers to enjoy wine reviews “outside the glass” — a brief escape from the 100-point-scale scores and in-depth analysis of wines that has dominated wine journalism for decades. Special thanks to vintners who joined in the fun, including the legendary Jean-Charles Boisset of Boisset Family Estates reading Thomas Matthew’s A White at the Oasis of Le Cirque,” Daryl Groom reading Thomas Matthew’s “Tony D’s Mystery Decanter,” and John Jordan reading “A Century-Old Wine Worth Staying Up Too Late,” written by former editor James Suckling.

Pour yourself a glass of your favorite wine and enjoy. We’d love to hear what you think. Subscribe to our blog or our YouTube channel, so you don’t miss our entire Real Winemakers Read Wine Spectator Reviews series. Real Sommeliers Read Robert Parker Reviews debuts next.

Nancie Mills Pipgras

These videos are brilliant. I feel like I’m the fly on the wall at a wine-maker-only dinner party where they pass around the latest copy of Spectator and have a ball with it. Don’t want to miss a one. Idea: A winemaker reading one while they’re in the field working? Juxtaposition of what it takes to make the wine and those oh-so-removed-from-the-process judgments of it?


Great idea! I can almost see it now … Sort of like the Paso Man videos by Dina Mande but just shot in one vineyard location. There are about four other What We’re Drinking Now columns from Spectator that would read very well. Love it.

This week’s hottest wine videos

[…] my blog-pal Lisa Mattson of Jordan winery comes this highly entertaining video, Real Winemakers Read Wine Spectator Reviews #2: Jean-Charles Boisset reads Thomas Matthews. Lisa explains below: “The legendary Jean-Charles Boisset makes a guest appearance on The […]

Ron Saikowski

I recommend Daniel “Danny Boy” Schuster, one of the world great winemaker consultants as your next reader!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Lisa Mattson

Videographer, photographer, writer and publicist. Find me on weekends trying to capture footage of the elusive Jordan Estate jack rabbits and turkeys.

Next Story

Real Winemakers Read Wine Spectator Reviews #1: John Jordan's Tribute to Real Actors Read Yelp Reviews

Reading Wine Spectator reviews on camera is more than a little outside my comfort zone, but in honor of Real Actors ...